I thought the productions totals after 5 years for both maps, played basically the same, were interesting. Map 1 without aging mod population was 46 (28 adults), map 2 with aging mod the population was 30 (12 adults). The totals were shown on the 2 overview pictures at the beginning of the thread.
Map 1 - 45 logs, 36 stone, 22 iron, 256 firewood, 124 tools, 94 clothes, 4,252 food, 117 herbs, 36 textiles.
Map 2 - 98 logs, 102 stone, 26 iron, 216 firewood, 68 tools, 90 clothes, 5,101 food, 105 herbs, 70 textiles.
With less than half the workers and a lot of micro-managing map 2 produced almost as well or in some cases better in the same amount of time. Factoring in the population difference, it would appear the production rate was about the same.